Guess who’s back? Back again. Another AK cake recipe is back. Tell yo friends.
Hopefully you get that Eminem song reference and if not, let’s just move along to this DAMN GOOD PEANUT BUTTER BANANA CAKE. And surprise: this easy banana cake is gluten free, grain free and easily dairy free too. It’s a little healthier than most cakes, making it perfect for kiddo’s birthdays, or just anytime you want a DAMN GOOD cake.
I created this recipe almost 5 years ago on a whim and shared it as one of my annual Valentine’s Day cake recipes. Since then, I’ve already made it countless times with various frostings (cream cheese, chocolate, vanilla and pb); but I found that pairing the peanut butter banana cake with peanut butter frosting was the clear winner. You know what they say: double the peanut butter, double the love.
Jk, that’s only me. ANYWAY, this cake is so good that I had to make it for the season finale of Good Mood Food. Watch it here or scroll below to see it!
Ingredients in this gluten free peanut butter banana cake recipe
- Almond flour: I recommend using a fine blanched almond flour. Make sure you pack the almond flour like you would with brown sugar!
- Coconut flour: this is a great gluten free flour to help absorb moisture in recipes and also add fiber and nutrition. No need to pack the coconut flour.
- Vanilla: an essential in baking.
- Eggs: this peanut butter banana cake recipe calls for four eggs to help create a fluffy consistency and texture. To make this cake vegan you could try using 4 flax eggs (4 tablespoons flaxseed meal + 12 tablespoons water), but please know that I haven’t tested a vegan verison.
- Bananas: you’ll get major delicious, moist banana bread vibes but in cake form (omg yes). Make sure your bananas are ripe to provide a good amount of all-natural sweetness.
- Pure maple syrup: I love love baking with pure maple syrup for a touch of sweetness and moisture in baking.
- Peanut butter: because it’s a peanut butter cake, of course! Be sure to use an all natural creamy peanut butter that has just peanuts + salt. I love this brand for anything/everything but Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods both sell awesome peanut butters with just peanuts + salt as the ingredients. You’ll use peanut butter in both the cake batter and the fluffy peanut butter frosting.
- Mini chocolate chips: everything’s better with a little chocolate, right? You’ll add some mini chocolate chips directly to the cake batter, but feel free to jazz it up with some on the top & sides after you frost. Feel free to use dairy free mini chocolate chips like these if you’d like.
- Butter: along with the creamy peanut butter, the frosting calls for butter to create an incredibly delicious peanut butter buttercream. Feel free to use a vegan buttery stick, too.
- Powdered sugar: adds the perfect amount of sweetness to the frosting. You can also try my paleo powdered sugar recipe!
Can I use different flour?
Unfortunately, no, I cannot recommend a flour substitute in this cake recipe as it will come out much differently. Please stick with the almond flour and coconut flour.
Dairy free and vegan swaps
- To make dairy free: simply use vegan butter in the frosting (such as Earth Balance) and dairy free chocolate chips (such as Enjoy Life).
- To make vegan: I haven’t tried making this cake vegan, but you could try replacing the eggs with flax eggs. Learn how to make flax eggs here, and let me know if the comments if you give it a shot! Then be sure to make the above dairy free swaps as well.
Let’s talk about the fluffy peanut butter frosting
Guys. This peanut butter frosting is fluffy, perfectly sweet and slightly addicting. To make it you’ll need just:
- Softened butter (or a vegan buttery stick)
- Powdered sugar
- Natural, creamy peanut butter
- Vanilla
- A few splashes of almond milk to make it extra creamy
Whip it up and spread it on to take this banana cake to the NEXT LEVEL. I re-tested it a couple of times to make it perfect, and let’s just say Abra and I were straight dipping apples in it the second time around. If you have extra frosting I’d recommend using it as a dip for your favorite fruit, pretzels, graham crackers or even a cookie recipe!
Tips for making this grain free peanut butter banana cake
- Use the right tools. You need a few essential kitchen tools for this recipe including: 6 inch cake pans (or you can use two 8-inch pans), parchment paper, an offset spatula for the frosting, a good set of mixing bowls and a cake stand.
- Use ripe bananas. Be sure you choose bananas with a few brown spots. This helps obtain the perfect cake texture, sweetness and consistency.
- Cool before frosting. Please be sure to follow the directions as written, and wait until the cake layers are completely cool before frosting them. After they are frosted, I recommend storing this gluten free peanut butter banana cake in the fridge for optimal freshness.
- Do a crumb coat. Frost the layers as you normally would, coat the outside of the cake with a very thin layer of frosting, and then place the cake in the fridge for 10-15 minutes before you finish frosting. This is so that the crumbs stick to this layer of frosting and not your main layer.
How to store this easy peanut butter banana cake
One of the best parts about this easy banana cake recipe is that you can make it 1-2 days ahead of time. I like to make the cakes ahead of time and keep them in the fridge for easy assemble, but you can also store it after you’ve frosted the cake too.
- To store: feel free to leave the fully-frosting peanut butter banana cake on the countertop wrapped in tinfoil for one day. After that, transfer the cake to the refrigerator for up to 5 days.
- To freeze: you can actually freeze this peanut butter banana cake either frosted or unfrosted for up to 2 months! When you’re ready to serve it, simply thaw it in the refrigerator overnight and then let the cake come to room temperature before serving.
More cake recipes you’ll love
- The Best Paleo Chocolate Cake with Paleo Chocolate Frosting
- Healthy Birthday Cake
- Inside Out Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cake
- Almond Lemon Raspberry Poppy Seed Cake
- Blow Ya Mind Pumpkin Cake with Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting (gluten free!)
Get all of my delicious cake recipes here!
I hope you love this grain free peanut butter banana cake as much as we did! If you make it, be sure to leave a comment below and rate the recipe. xo!
Good Mood Food Episode 10
Ambitious Kitchen
Cookbook
125 Ridiculously Good For You, Sometimes Indulgent, and Absolutely Never Boring Recipes for Every Meal of the Day
Damn Good Peanut Butter Banana Cake (gluten free, grain free)
Ingredients
- Wet ingredients
- 3 very overripe medium bananas, mashed (1 ¼ cup mashed overripe banana)
- 4 large eggs, at room temperature
- ¾ cup (234g) pure maple syrup
- ¾ cup (192g) natural creamy peanut butter (only peanuts & salt as ingredients)
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- Dry ingredients
- 2 cups (224g) packed super fine blanched almond flour (I use Bob's Red Mill)
- ½ cup (56g) coconut flour (do not pack)
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 1 cup (180g) mini chocolate chips, dairy free if desired
- For the frosting:
- ½ cup (113g) butter, at room temperature (or sub vegan butter)
- ½ cup (128g) natural creamy peanut butter (just peanuts + salt)
- 2 cups (226g) powdered sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- 2-3 tablespoons unsweetened almond milk (or milk of choice), to make the frosting creamy
- To garnish the cake:
- Mini chocolate chips around the edges of the cake
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Line the bottom of three 6-inch round cake pans or two 8-inch round cake pans with parchment paper rounds. Spray parchment paper and sides of pan with nonstick cooking spray. YOU SHOULD USE PARCHMENT PAPER or the cake is likely to stick. Please do not forget.
- In a large bowl, whisk together mashed bananas, eggs, pure maple syrup, peanut butter and vanilla extract until smooth.
- In a large bowl, whisk the almond flour, coconut flour, baking soda and salt together. Set aside. Add dry ingredients to wet ingredients and mix with a wooden spoon until well combined. Fold in mini chocolate chips.
- Divide batter evenly between pans and spread out with a spatula to smooth the tops. Bake for 20-30 minutes if using two 8-inch pans and 25-35 minutes for three 6-inch pans. Cakes are done when a tester comes out clean or with just a few crumbs attached. Allow cake to cool completely before frosting or removing from the pans. The cake should be room temperature or cold when you frost it. This is very important. Cakes can be made a day ahead and stored in the fridge if you’d like.
- Make your frosting: In the bowl of an electric mixer, add the softened butter and peanut butter and whip on high until light and fluffy. Add powdered sugar, vanilla and 2 tablespoons almond milk. Beat slow at first, then increase speed to high and beat for approximately two minutes. Frosting should be nice and creamy, if you want it extra creamy, add another tablespoon of almond milk and beat again.
- Now it’s time to frost the cake: place about 1-2 tablespoons down onto the cake stand and spread out. Invert 1 cake onto the cake stand, add about ½ heaping cup frosting between each layer, repeat with each cake, then frost the top and sides of the cake with the remaining frosting. If you’d like, you can do a crumb coat for the frosting first (to avoid crumbs in the frosting) by doing the following: Frost the layers as you normally would and then coat the outside of the cake with a very thin layer of frosting and place in fridge for 10-15 minutes before you finish frosting. This is so that the crumbs stick to this layer of frosting and not your main layer.
- Cake will stay good for 5-7 days in the fridge, and should be covered to ensure freshness. Serves 16.
Recipe Notes
Recipe by: Monique Volz // Ambitious Kitchen | Photography by: Eat Love Eats
Can’t wait to try this! Any suggestions for almond flour substitute for those w/ an almond allergy?
Love your stuff!
Have you ever tried cashew flour? I have seen people use it in place of almond and i believe you can get it on amazon!
Feel free to use hazelnut or pecan flour instead of almond flour!
I substituted with oat flour because we have a tree nut allergy in my family and it worked beautifully. It’s no longer grain free, but I used gluten free oats to keep it gluten free.
Hey Brooke,
Could you tell me the conversion you used for the oat flour instead of almond flour? Thanks!
So glad those swaps worked out well! The perfect dessert 🙂
My level of excitement for this cake is… scary hahaha! looks AMAZING OMG!!!
YES it’s so amazing! Let me know when you get a chance to try it!
This looks divine! Thanks for all the tips.
Absolutely! Hope you get a chance to try it 🙂
I’m allergic to peanuts! Thoughts on using … cashew butter? almond butter? can’t decide what would work best!
Either would be fine! I would probably suggest cashew but it just depends on what nut butter you like more.
holy crud this looks delicious.
Thanks Dana! So. Delicious.
Hi! This looks SO fantastic. I can’t have almond flour (booo) but would oat flour be an okay substitute? Or chickpea flour?
Hi! Feel free to use hazelnut or pecan flour instead of almond flour.
This cake is amazing! Super easy to make and the taste is superb. You can fully taste all the flavors and they combine together beautifully. Thank you for another great recipe!
I’m so glad you loved it! One of my favorite flavor combos, too 🙂
Hi! Have you ever made this but into cupcakes?
Hi! I haven’t tried it yet but bake temp would be the same. I would check the cupcakes around 18-25 minutes.
I made them as cupcakes and they were great! I made less frosting and stuff had some leftover. I just kept an eye on them but I would say my bake time was around 20 minutes.
Perfect!!
can’t wait to try!! What would the modifications be to make this without layers in a 9×13 baking pan?
Same temp and check the cake around 20-30 minutes. Make sure to grease your pan!
I’m looking to make this as a smash cake for my one-year old. Is there a recommendation you have for substituting the powdered sugar for the frosting with another natural sweetener? Would like to avoid refined sugars or any type of artificial sweetener. Thank you in advance!
Feel free to try my paleo powdered sugar!
Oh, what a beautiful cake! I would love to make it for the 19th birthday of my daughter 🙂
That would be perfect! Let me know if you try it!
This cake is AMAZING!! I made a few modifications that I was a little nervous about, and it still turned out great.
I subbed oat flour for almond flour, flax eggs for eggs, and ghee for butter. All substitutions were 1 for 1 and it was perfect.
Cant wait to try this! Do you think this recipe would work as cupcakes? Any advice on cooking instructions?
Hi! I haven’t tried it yet but bake temp would be the same. I would check the cupcakes around 18-25 minutes.
Can I use almond butter or cashew butter instead of peanut?
Yes either should work!
This cake was a hit with my entire family (8 years to 88 years)! How do you keep the icing so pure white?! Mine turned out a deep tan color. It was delicious but not as pretty :/
The peanut butter frosting will be a light to medium tan color. It probably just depends on the color of your peanut butter. Also if you are using a paleo powdered sugar (such as paleo coconut sugar) that makes a big difference in color.
Can I get use brown sugar instead of maple syrup?
I can’t wait to make this!
I haven’t tried it, but if you’d like you can use 1 cup coconut sugar. Let me know how it turns out!
This was delicious! I used two 9in cake pans and baked for 20 minutes. The cake was moist and the frosting is creamy and not too sweet. Yum!!
Perfect! So glad you loved it!
Can I substitute regular flour for the almond/coconut flour? I have no gluten sensitives and don’t have those flours on hand. This sounds delicious either way!
Unfortunately a regular, all purpose flour won’t work in this one-to-one – sorry!
Hi!
This looks delicious and I plan on making it tonight. Can I use a general all purpose gluten free flour with same ratios or do you just recommend the 2 separate flours?
Thank you!
Hi Rebeka! It would be a completely different cake, so I’m not sure. Almond flour and coconut flour have unique absorbent properties and flavors so I recommend sticking to the recipe 🙂
Just made the Damn Good Peanut Butter Banana Cake- first off, can’t believe how easy it was, and second off can’t believe it’s gluten free and only sweetened with bananas and maple syrup!! Made this in a 9 x 13 pan and baked at 350 degrees for about 25 min. Same frosting recipe- perfect amount! Thanks for this deliciousness!
Amazing! So glad you enjoyed and that it worked out well as a sheet cake – YUM.
Honestly not the best AK recipe. I’d say 99% are amazing but this ones just very unappealing. Icing is kind of weird. Edible but like more as a “healthy” snack than as a dessert. Thanks anyway 🙂
Sorry to hear you didn’t like this one, Hanna! I’m not sure where things went wrong as the icing is a pretty basic peanut butter buttercream. Glad you’re finding other recipes here that you like!
Can this cake be considered healthy?
Everyone’s definition of healthy is different, but I consider the more natural ingredients to be healthier than in traditional cakes 🙂
I made this recipe for my boyfriend on Valentine’s Day. After taking the first bite, he was SPEECHLESS. I’m a regular baker so he’s used to sampling what I’m baking. For this recipe, he said “This is the best thing you’ve ever made! A restaurant quality cake!” He then asked for a second helping, and asked if he could have some for breakfast this morning. This cake is a winner!
Amazing!! So happy to hear that 🙂 perfect Valentine’s Day treat!
This TRULY is damn good. I made it for Valentine’s Day and holy delicious it’s amazing. I made the recipe as is, but divided it amongst two 8” round pans and two 6” round pans. The layers were maybe 1-1 1/2” thick but still a night height for 4 layers. The frosting amount was perfect for the middle layers, a crumb layer, and the top layer. If you are wondering about making it, DO IT!!
Perfect! So happy you loved it – yum!
Just made this for my son’s 6th Birthday and couldn’t help but taking a bite out of the side to, of course, test it :). It was WONDERFUL! I made it in a 9×13 glass pan and decorated the top with mini choc chips in his name. He is going to love it!
Amazing! Love that 🙂 I hope he loves it, too!
I made it for my husband’s birthday and everyone loved it. It tastes like banana bread topped with peanut butter frosting. It was delicious!
So happy to hear that! My fav, too 🙂
Made this 2 times already! SOOOOOO DAMN GOOD!
YES love that, Ema!
I made this cake for my husbands birthday, I love to bake, but I have never made an actual cake before. This cake was so easy to make that my kids helped and it was so delicious we ate it every night until it was gone!
So happy to hear that, Shannon! The perfect birthday cake 🙂
Made the cake for hubby’s birthday and the whole family loved it! Frosting was the bomb!
Love it! So happy to hear that.
No joke 3rd time I am making this cake in I think 2 weeks? We can’t get enough of it! Ran out of chocolate chips this time so it will be chipless… sad but honestly we just had to make it regardless!
Love that!! The best 🙂
I followed the recipe to the T and it came out amazing. I wouldn’t change a thing.
So happy to hear that!
This cake was absolutely delicious but mine did not rise very well. Any idea why? It was extreme dense but still good . I also thought it could use more frosting .
That’s odd. Is your baking soda fresh and did you follow the recipe exactly? It will be a bit more dense because of the gluten free flours, but should not end up extremely dense.
I decided to try this just on the reviews it was getting and had a party Saturday so perfect timing. It was cut into and finished before I even thought about taking a picture lol. The icing is the bomb. Thank you ambitious kitchen for another successful cake. People always ask me where I get my recipes and I always say “My Girl”. Your my favourite blogger!! Always look forward to the next one.
Amazing! I’m so glad everyone loved it and that you’re finding your fav recipes here 🙂 Thanks, Kathy!
I did not have enough maple syrup so I used about half maple syrup and 1/2 molasses. The frosting, I used swerve with the regular confection sugar. The cake was delicious and those I shared with really liked it! Will definitely make again !
I’m glad those swaps worked out well! Such a great dessert.
I’m planning on making this today for my husbands birthday. I couldn’t find coconut flour anywhere! Can I sub oat flour for the coconut flour? Also there was no parchment paper 😭😭😭. If I use non stick pans and oil spray do you think they will come out of the pans ok???
I haven’t tried this with oat flour but i suspect that it might work just fine! I might recommend adding a little more oat flour — maybe 1/4 cup. I recommend REALLY oiling up the pans. Otherwise you could make this in a 9×13 inch pan so you don’t have to worry about the cakes coming out of the pans!
Omg the icing is so delicious 😋 I want to bathe in it 😂😂😂
But really this cake is so good you won’t believe it’s gluten free ! 😂💕
My fav!! Glad you love it!
This cake was AMAZING! My sister is gluten intolerant so we are always on the lookout for good gluten free desserts. First off, as an avid baker, this was super easy to make. Everything came together easily. Everyone agreed that it was delicious, and my mom even commented “this is gluten free?”. Would definitely make again. I made it exactly as written without any problems.
Amazing! So happy you gave this one a try!
Hi! Is coconut flour necessary? May i leave it out?
Hi! It is necessary in here for the cake to bake up properly.
MAKE THIS CAKE! It was soooo delicious and easy to make. A big hit in my house and perfectly moist… yes I said the word but it’s true. Better than any store bought GF cake I’ve had!
So glad you loved it!
This was really good! I used this exact recipe to make cupcakes instead of cake – it yielded 18 cupcakes and the cook time was 20 minutes. They were kinda like a muffin, but when you frosted them, they were cupcakes! (we ate leftovers for breakfast).
Really good, moist, great texture and very tasty.
Delicious! Love that idea!
I’ve been wanting to make this cake since you first shared it, and I finally made it today! It really is mmm, mmm, damn good!! I will make this again and again!!
So glad you loved it! One of my favs 🙂
I made this for Easter but halved the recipe and it turned out great. My one and four year old ate it right up and my husband said it’s the best dessert we’ve had in awhile. The perfect amount of sweet without being over powering. It tastes like a delicious banana bread with frosting on it- yum!
Perfect! So glad everyone enjoyed 🙂
This was so easy to make and delicious!! I made this for Easter and added sprinkles to the top of it. I made it into a sheet cake and baked at the same temp for about 22 minutes. This will definitely be a repeat recipe in our house.
Amazing! So glad you enjoyed!
This might be THE BEST recipe I have ever encountered…and on top of that, it is pretty easy! My family made me promise to make this every holiday. They couldn’t get enough! 12/10 must try!
Amazing! So happy to hear that, Charlotte!
We loved this cake! I made it vegan using egg substitute, vegan butter and it was delish!! Definitely a new favorite 👏🏻
Amazing! Glad that worked out well 🙂 the perfect dessert!
I discovered your blog about a year ago, and I have tried many of your recipes. I baked this for my birthday during home quarantine and it was amazing! Love the frosting! can’t stop licking it. Thank you very much for the amazing recipe! Love from Indonesia 🙂
Amazing! I’m so glad you found AK 🙂 one of my favorite recipes, too!
This cake in incredible! I made it for Easter and will be making it again for Mother’s Day. It was so moist and delicious, huge hit with my family! I typically don’t bake cakes but this recipe was easy and so good. Thank you!
Amazing! So happy to hear that 🙂
Since quarantine began, I have made this 4 times. The cake recipe is also perfect sans icing for muffins or in a single layer for a healthy peanut butter banana bread! However, the frosting is divine. I’ve been making half a batch as muffins and the other half in an 8 in round cake pan. I make a half batch of the frosting for the cake, but the muffins are for mornings and snacks. Irresistible both ways!
Had to up my cardio because I’m only cooking for two… 😀
Amazing! Glad you love this one!!
This cake was DELICIOUS!! I made it into a 6-layer cake in my air fryer because the circuit to my oven was broken. It took super long because I had to cook each layer separately, but man was it worth it! Also, the peanut butter frosting is addicting – I couldn’t stop sneaking tastes from the bowl. Highly recommend!!
Amazing that it worked in your air fryer! And yes, obsessed with that frosting 😉
FIVE STARS!!!! (Star rating isn’t working for me). Made this today with my 2 year old daughter for her *graduation* and it was easy and delicious, although there were a few little hiccups! I used 2 round 6-inch cake pans and filled them almost all the way to the top, maybe left about 1/2 inch, and they rose beautifully BUT the centers of the cakes later collapsed while cooling on the countertop. IDK if this happened bc I overfilled them??… this is the first cake I make, even though I have been baking tons of other things for many years, and I didn’t have a third cake pan so I tried to pack it into two– and I was hoping it would work but had a bad feeling. Oh well– just wondering if that could have been avoided.
We also had enough batter left to fill one entire silicone baking cup which made one HUGE cupcake (the size of a baseball) with a beautiful rounded top and my toddler at the whole thing!! I would definitely use this recipe to make healthy cupcakes in the future.
Lastly, made a rookie mistake with the frosting… didn’t have powdered sugar so I ground up some organic raw cane sugar into a fine powder but found it made the frosting extremely sweet and BROWN. :/ Now did some research and found out that cane sugar is minimally processed and does not have the molasses removed. Granulated sugar, however, does have the molasses removed and can be ground up to make powdered sugar. Will definitely need to buy some next time. 😉
… and with all of that, the cake is still amazing!!! 🙂 Sharing my experiences just in case they can help someone else! Happy baking! 😉
Back to comment that our cake was way too moist so I imagine it was very undercooked after 30 mins, possibly bc the cake pans were pretty full, so the texture (and taste) was just like cookie dough… this seems like it would be the reason the centers collapsed. The cupcake, though, was well done at 30 mins, yet still moist, and it was the proper texture. Big bummer but a learning experience. Don’t overfill your pans!
Yes, you need to use 3 6-inch pans like the recipe calls for. Or else it’s too much batter and I’m not sure it would bake well. Let me know if you give it another try! 🙂
This cake looks delicious! I am going to make it for my one year old’s birthday who is obsessed with bananas and peanut butter. Do you know if I can sub all-purpose flour for the almond and coconut flours? Thank you!
Such a great combo! I wouldn’t suggest subbing all purpose flour in this as the texture and flavors will really change. Try these cupcakes instead!
Wow, this cake is amazing!! I did keto it by adding sugar free waldon farm syrup and also used Swerve confection for the icing and finally added Lily’s milk choco sugar free chips. It turned out super moist and delicious and my family had no idea it was sugar free. This recipe is a keeper. I made it in 2 8′ pans and baked it for 25 minutes. This will be a staple in my house from here on in. Thanks for the awesome recipe
I’m glad that worked out well! The perfect dessert 🙂
O.m.g. I made this for fathers day weekend and my husband absolutely loves it. It is highly addicting if u love peanut butter.
I let my cakes sit out over night last night and I frosted it this am. Just enough frosting to cover it all. Thank you for this heavenly cake.
Amazing! So happy to hear that!
Made this cake last night for my family and it was by far the very best GF DF cake I have ever had! Kudos to the chef! Flavor and texture were not compromised! By accident I used 3x 9 inch pans and although the layers were thinner it still came out perfect. I thought I had coconut flour (but didn’t) so had to substitute GF baking flour and it came out wonderfully! This cake will be moved up to my “need to make again” list. If you didn’t tell anyone it was GF no one would be able to tell. Excellent recipe!!
Amazing! I’m glad it still worked out well in those pans and with the GF baking flour 🙂
This was the very first recipe of yours I ever made and it was a HUGE hit. I made it for a get together with my girlfriends, one in which has celiac, so I wanted to make something delicious for her! At the time, I had a two month old and was trying to juggle being a first time mama and make this yummy cake, so I wasn’t sure how it would turn out (because I had total mom brain). My friends LOVED it and so did I! I then went to another get together with my son and husband with some of my husbands work friends and decided to bring the leftover. It was demolished and also a huge hit because it is gluten free. I will definitely be making this again and again!
Amazing!! So happy to hear that, Linda. I can totally relate to juggling a newborn + trying to do anything in the kitchen 🙂 glad everyone enjoyed!
Hi! Can I use normal flour for this recipe instead?
Thanks!
Hi! Unfortunately regular will not work in this recipe. Sorry!
I’ve made this cake probably 5 times. It’s unbelievable. Everyone who tries it is blown away and can’t believe the cake is gluten free and refined sugar free (minus the frosting which has confectionery sugar but it’s to die for)
So happy to hear that!!
Would I be able to eliminate the added sugar completely by subbing the 3/4 cup maple syrup for another banana?
I wouldn’t suggest it but maybe you could do an extra large banana and 1/4 cup milk. Again, I haven’t tested it so I’m not sure it would work.
This was one of the easiest and most delicious from scratch caked I’ve ever made. I don’t normally do gluten free baking but we had a guest we wanted to accommodate for a birthday celebration. No one knew it was gluten free and my biggest junk eaters raved about it. The only hard part for me was getting the chocolate chips on the side of the cake.. any tips would be welcome. My family is already making requests for this cake for upcoming birthdays.. this will be a staple!
I’m so glad! Check out the video for an easy-ish way to put them on – not perfect but still delicious 🙂
So excited to make this! Did you use sweet or semisweet chocolate chips?
It’s amazing! I usually use semisweet or dark chocolate chips 🙂
I’d like to make this, but don’t have any maple syrup. Can I substitute brown sugar? Will the lack of a wet ingredient make a difference?
I would recommend using a liquid sweetener, honey would be a good option or date syrup.
Hi ma’am! I just wanted to know if I could use Whole Wheat Flour instead of Almond Flour and Coconut Flour?
Hi! Unfortunately I would not recommend that as the texture and taste will really change. Sorry!
Would the Bob’s red mill Gluten free all purpose 1 to 1 baking flour work instead of the almond flour listed above?
I haven’t tried it, but I can’t say I would recommend, sorry!
OMG! This is definitely one damn good cake! I love this cake, I’ve made it several times. No one can tell it’s gluten free and healthier! This is definitely in my rotation for cakes. Thanks for another AMAZING cake recipe Monique!
This one is one of our favs! Glad you love it, too!
I’ve made this twice and I find that this cake is foolproof, so delicious, so worth the time, so worth the costly ingredients. People are shocked when I tell them it’s gluten free!
Absolutely! One of my all time favs!
This cake is nothing short of spectacular. It was super moist and the flavors really shone. Thank you for the great recipe!
My daughter made this for her 2 year old’s birthday this weekend. She used 2 8 inch pans. What a delicious cake. She wanted something more healthy for her son and family. I wanted to make him a “normal” sweet cake, lol. Glad she showed me!!! Now I have this recipe and will be making it for co workers. Thank you for a wonderful moist and delicious cake!
Amazing! Such a great birthday treat 🙂
I’ve made this cake before and absolutely love it! I only have 8 in cake pans now, can i still use the same amounts for the recipe or should I double it to make 3 8 in cake pans? Or keep the recipe the same? I’m making it for a large party and I’m not sure which to do
I would make 2 — 8 inch pans as the recipe suggests!
Very delicious! Indulgent, but not too heavy at the same time. You can definitely taste the banana in this cake – if you like banana bread, you’ll love this (it’s essentially a dessert version).
I’d like to try this cake without the chocolate chips, since I felt like it had a lot of flavors going on already. While not my favorite, I must say the frosting is addicting!! My mom and I kept dipping our fingers into it!
Feel free to leave the chocolate chips out! Glad you both enjoyed 🙂
I sent this recipe to my friend who loves to bake & create “healthy” treats. She made this & it was AMAZING!!! it is the best cake I’ve ever eaten. She saved the extra frosting & her & I couldn’t stop eating it!! So delicious. Also the cake looks so beautiful & decadent on a cake stand. Fancy looking but so easy to make. Thanks I Love your recipes!!
Love that! So happy you both enjoyed!
Made this recipe with regular flour (mix of white all purpose and whole wheat) instead of almond and coconut flour. I used appropriate ratios, adding 4 cups of flour total and the batter was extremely thick and doughy. Then added 3 Tb. water to thin the mixture, but the cake still came out very thick and a bit doughy in the middle (probably just didn’t cook it long enough), more like bread texture than cake. Still tasted amazing though, and was a hit with the whole family! Definitely will be checking out more ak recipes!
I’m glad it was a hit! The flour swap is likely what changed the texture, so I’d recommend sticking with the original recipe to get the best result 🙂
I’m trying to avoid processed sugar, is there a substitute I can sue for the icing sugar?
Check out the full blog posts for suggested swaps! You can use my paleo powdered sugar.
I wasn’t sure what I was expecting for the cake, but it was insane! I didn’t have round cake pans, so I baked it in a glass 13×9 dish with parchment paper on the bottom for 35-40 minutes (I started checking it at 25 minutes and kept adding 5 of the toothpick didn’t come out clean).
The cake itself reminds me of a chocolatey, moist, banana bread. The frosting is like fluffy peanut butter pie mixture. The pairing of them makes for an amazing cake!
Highly recommend this recipe!
Perfect! So happy you loved this one!
This looks wonderful. Do you happen to have nutritional information for this cake (calories, etc?) thank you
I don’t calculate nutrition for my more indulgent recipes like this one, but you’ll find it on my other recipes! Enjoy 🙂
@Monique, I wish you guys would publish the nutrition facts for ALL recipes on this wonderful website, even the more “indulgent” ones because I am a firm believer that anyone is allowed to indulge and still fit this into their macros for the day. Providing us with the nutrition facts allows us to determine how much we can indulge each day, if we’re keeping track. 😉 Just wanted to mention that. I know it’s a lot of work though. Took me a good 30-45 mins to come up with these macros, so I absolutely had to share with others here. Feel free to publish what I wrote!! 🙂
(I posted this above in the comment to Jenifer but realized you might not see it, Monique, so I decided to reply directly to you also. sorry for the double post!)
@Jenifer – I calculated out the macros since I am tracking them now, and I can share!
PROTEIN: 12.81g
CARBS: 51.09g
FAT: 28.3g
CALORIES: 485
that’s for 1 serving only, and there are 16 servings in this cake, according to AK.
If you want the full cake macros, just multiply each number by 16 or by how many slices you plan to eat. One serving weighs approximately 132g, BTW, in case you prefer to weigh your portions out!
@Monique, I wish you guys would publish the nutrition facts for ALL recipes on this wonderful website, even the more “indulgent” ones because I am a firm believer that anyone is allowed to indulge and still fit this into their macros for the day. Providing us with the nutrition facts allows us to determine how much we can indulge each day, if we’re keeping track. 😉 Just wanted to mention that. I know it’s a lot of work though. Took me a good 30-45 mins to come up with these macros, so I absolutely had to share with others here. Feel free to publish what I wrote!! 🙂
PS: It goes without saying I am obsessed with this recipe, so is my BF, and we’ve made it like 5+ times now. I have found that I prefer less powdered sugar and more peanut butter in my frosting, but you have to adjust and mix carefully… otherwise the frosting will turn out more like a fondant and less fluffy! (Which I was OK with, LOL.) We didn’t own three 6″ cake pans for the longest time. After making this as-written, with the 6″ pans I can confidently say it LOOKS more “impressive” and professional than when I did it with only 2 layers in two ~8″ cake pans. But it was much harder to slice into 16 equal portions using the 6″ diameter pan. Much, much harder but I also suck at cutting things evenly! So I may go back to the larger diameter pan just due to convenience sake. 😉
I think this is my new favorite cake. It’s incredible! I used PB2 for the peanut butter in the frosting, Lets’ say, that’s not the best route. The icing doesn’t hold the correct consistency with it (at least not over time). I ended up making it look like it was done on purpose and put tons of mini choc chips where all the icing drained into the plate, making a moat of chips & icing. Such a fabulous recipe though! Just don’t take the shortcut I tried.
So glad you loved it! And yes, PB2 will probably give the icing a strange texture. I suggest sticking with regular PB!
Hi Monique! Thank you for the recipe. Is it ok to use frozen bananas, thawed, as long as it amounts to 1.25 c mashed ripe banana? TIA
This cake is incredible!! I made this for my husband’s birthday today & he said it’s the best cake he’s ever had! My toddler and I had a lot of fun baking it together & she couldn’t wait to try it. Thank you so much for creating such amazing recipes with great ingredients! My family enjoys them so much! I may even make this without the chocolate chips for my son’s first birthday coming up. Thanks again!
Hi !
Is there an alternative recipe for using normal flour please??
Thanks!
Hi! Unfortunately I can’t recommend alternative flours in this recipe. Sorry!
What are the calories per serving?
I don’t calculate nutrition for my more indulgent recipes like this one as they’re meant to be a special treat 🙂
@Cheryl: I calculated the calories per serving to be approximately 485 cal.
If you scroll up to Jenifer’s post, I put the full macros in my reply to her. I am hoping AK will publish them. I an not a professional and I just did this in Excel today so bear that in mind…and your calories may vary slightly if you used different brands of ingredients. e.g. mine was calculated using Ghirardelli mini dark chocolate chips.
I made this cake using the flax egg modification to make it vegan and it turned out great! My non-vegan family members said it was the best cake they’ve ever had! I have a feeling this cake will become my go-to for using ripe bananas!
Looking forward to making this for Valentine’s Day! Sorry if I missed it but salted or unsalted butter?
This cake is AMAZING! I dream of having a reason to make it. The first time I made it, it was to celebrate buying our first home last May. My birthday is this weekend and I’ve been so excited to have a reason to make it again!!
I made this for myself for my birthday last year and it came out perfectly! I gave a piece to a friend (the rest was for me, duh) and she still raves about this cake. I can’t wait to make it again ASAP.
This cake is amazing!! I always go to your site to find recipes to use up over ripe bananas, typically I do muffins. I’m a big cake person and often have issues with the texture of grain free or gluten free cakes but this did not disappoint. I made a 3 layer 6 inch cake and only had enough frosting for a semi-naked cake so if I were to make it for an occasion I’d prob up the quantities.
Amazing! So glad you enjoyed!
We halved this recipe and replaced the maple syrup with 2T of almond milk (as Monique suggested on IG) for my son’s smash cake — it was a big hit!!
My husband made me this cake for my bday and it turned out amazing! It was his first time making a cake and your recipe was easy to follow!
Would you be able to make a recipe with cassava flour?
Thanks!
This cake is amazing! I subbed almond butter for peanut butter (just what we had in the pantry) and it was delicious! I made this as my one year olds smash cake and everyone at the party was digging in after he finished. It was a hit! Now everyone is requesting this cake for their birthday! Amazing recipe and so easy- made a day ahead.
I made this for our little superbowl gathering with my work pod last week. I loved it so much, and so did everyone of my workmates! The FROSTING. OH MY GOODNESS, new go to frosting for other things, choco cupcakes, muffins, etc. YUM. I have gotten requests to make the frosting for eating straight from the bowl!
My one question is that I wanted to know if I could substitute another flour for almond flour. I know most alternative flours are water intensive, but I don’t eat/buy almonds and pistachios as a rule since they are such a water intensive crop. Could I substitute some other flour for almond flour in your recipes??
So glad it was a hit! Hmmm you could try hazelnut flour, but know the flavor will have that hazelnutty flavor 🙂
made this for my one year olds birthday – she gobbled it up, and it was a hit for my husband and i too. i didnt include the maple syrup at all and it was still moist, sweet, and delicious.
I’m glad it still worked out well!
This is one of the best things I’ve ever baked. I made it for myself for my birthday during the early days of COVID. I had fully planned to freeze half, but couldn’t do it and just put it in the fridge and ate it for a week. I almost cried when it was gone. Sadly, I am not exaggerating. I followed the recipe exactly (except for storing in my fridge 2 days longer than recommended, I do not apologize) and had a perfect result. Excuse me while I go and find a reason to bake this cake again.
So glad you loved it!! Always an excuse to make cake 🙂
This is the BEST cake! I don’t love cake and typically pass up on it but not this one. It’s become the staple in our house for any big celebration or birthday!
Made this yesterday and it was a huge hit with my family! Everyone loved it and couldn’t get enough! The recipe is super easy to follow. Will definitely be making this again! Thank you for an awesome recipe!
I’m so glad! Perfect treat 🙂
Five stars is not enough for this cake. I’ve made it 4 times (would not recommend subbing full-sized choc chips or using different pans than the two options listed) and every time people are addicted. I always have a few tablespoons of frosting left over – which is really a gift to find in your fridge when you need a taste of something super rich and delicious. Perfect for events or just because you deserve it.
Amazing! And the best treat to have leftover frosting.
I was nervous to make this, as I have never made a cake from scratch, but it turned out amazing! It was delicious and I will definitely be making it again.
So glad it turned out well!
So delicious! I made these in to cupcakes and they turned out great! 20-22 minutes was the perfect bake time for my oven. The frosting really makes these a decadent treat but this is also great without frosting. Stored in the fridge and served chilled is our favorite way to enjoy these.
Perfect! Love the idea of making cupcakes 🙂
OMG-made this last night and it was SO good! Followed the recipe to a T and made cupcakes(bake time was 20 mins)
The cake is rich and flavorful but not too sweet and the icing pairs perfectly. It tastes like a cake for a special occasion but is fairly easy to make. Definitely a keeper!
Amazing! So glad you enjoyed!
Most amazing recipe! I made this for my daughters smash cake photo shoot and she absolutely loved it (and so did mom and dad)! I didn’t use any powdered sugar in the frosting I just used 2.5 TBSP of maple syrup and it turned out just as good! I will be making this for all of our celebrations.
Love that! Perfect treat for celebrating 🙂
Ambitious Kitchen is one of my favorite websites and the best variety of wonderful recipes! I am hooked and every dish and dessert I have made has been awesome! I find the prep times tend to take longer than noted but I’m no pro and have a small kitchen! Keep the recipes flowing Monique! You rock!
So happy to hear that, Kristin! Thanks so much for your note 🙂 I hope you keep finding recipes here that you love!
I make AK recipes constantly. If I crave something, I see if they have a recipe for it first. This cake is no exception. AMAZING. I added walnuts because I had them and it tastes even better refrigerated. Incredible. AK: making pandemic paleo pregnancies better one recipe at a time.
Amazing! So happy to hear that 🙂
YES, YES, YES, this cake is A+++++! The directions were so easy to follow and made it so simple for me to successfully make the best cake ever. If you love peanut butter you MUST make this cake.
So glad you loved it!!
The cake turned out to be great and everyone enjoyed . I baked 2 sets in 9 inch pans. Thank you, we did it for my son’s birthday.
Pefect! Glad everyone loved it!
This was truly amazing! I made it for Easter Sunday and followed the recipe exactly. I could have eaten the entire cake by itself. It was a perfect marriage of peanut butter, bananas, and chocolate. I will DEFINITELY make it again!
So glad you loved it! One of my favs, too 🙂
I’ve always made a peanut butter cake ND frosting , but can’t wait to try this. I will post comment after I taste it and let ya know.
Hope you love this one! Let me know how it goes 🙂
This cake made having a 30th birthday in quarantine WORTH IT. Best cake ever – ate it every,single.night. until it was gone. 10/10 making for every birthday.
Love it!! Happy birthday!
Likes how u come up with vegan options.
I’m so glad I found this site. It has so many recipes that I can use. That Peanut butter Cake looks scrumptious!! Can’t wait to make it!
I’m so glad you found AK, too! Hope you find tons of recipes here that you love 🙂
Question? Could I use regular ingredients (reg flour/peanut butter etc) or would it effect the outcome? Sorry, no? No i am not an experienced baker to change ingredients and effect in product. Thank you!
I wouldn’t recommend it – sorry! The flavor and texture will be much different.
WOW! This is my first time ever making a gluten free/grain free anything,,and was I surprised at how moist and flavorful it was. Has anyone made this? Im thinking of cutting back on the chocolate chips and adding walnuts? Can’t wait to make more recipes on here.
So glad you loved it! Many people have made this 🙂 If you scroll below the recipe and click “Show Comments” you’ll see all of those. Walnuts sound great in here, too!
Curious about the total amount of carbohydrates and sugars in this cake? I’m changing my lifestyle after reading Dr. Fung’s book called “The Obesity Code” where you intermittent fast while significantly reducing your consumption of refined sugar and refined grains…. Just curious! Can’t wait to make it either way!
Hi! I don’t calculate nutrition for my more indulgent recipes as they’re meant to be a special treat 🙂 You’ll find that most of my other recipes (desserts included) have all of this info!
Can I substitute AP flour – 1:1 ratio? -thank you!
I wouldn’t recommend it – sorry! The texture and flavor will be much different.
Wow! This cake was absolutely delicious! I actually made it for myself for my own birthday because peanut butter, chocolate and bananas are my favorites. It was truly bakery quality. Everyone loved it and I felt good about the cake being healthier than a store bought cake loaded with refined sugar. Thank you for sharing this damn good cake!
So happy to hear that! Perfect dessert 🙂
Would love to try this but prefer to use regular white flour and other standard ingredients. Could you possibly make suitable conversions to those for me? Thank you.
Hi! Unfortunately I’ve only made the cake as-is so I cannot recommend flour substitutes in this one. Sorry!
This is a really good cake! Yummy!!! I used swerve confectioners sugar substitute for the frosting, oh, mercy! I loved it! I did the two layer cake instead of the 3 layer. I recommend this cake.
I’m glad that worked out well! Perfect dessert 🙂
Absolutely amazing 😍😍😍 so light and has the perfect combo of peanut butter, bananas and chocolate chip! Made this for friends and they all loved it and were asking for the recipe 😜
So glad it was a hit!!
Looking good Can’t wait to try it
Hope you love it!
Made this yesterday and it is to die for!
So glad you loved it!!
I’m not someone who usually cares for cake. But this… this is incredible. It leans towards banana bread with peanut butter icing, which, honestly, is all I want in a cake anyway. My husband made this for my birthday, and I was so upset when it was all gone. This will probably be my birthday cake for the foreseeable future, if not the rest of my life.
Isn’t it amazing?? Our favorite cake for birthdays and holidays, too 🙂
this cake is so so so good. I just made it for a second time today. It’s everything I want in a cake!
Amazing!! So happy to hear you’re loving it, Lauren 🙂
Delicious! I halved the recipe and baked for 32 minutes in an 8×8 Pyrex pan. Super moist and flavorful – will definitely make again!
Glad to hear that worked out and that you enjoyed it, Brogan!
I tried an 8×8 pan and cooked it for an hour and it was still a soggy sticky blob on the inside of the entire thing.
Followed the recipe to a T but cooked it in an 8×8 square pan and it is garbage. We all ate a piece of the banana choc mush but no one’s going back for seconds lol. I am a horrid baker but this is the worst anything has ever turned out for me.
So sorry to hear that. It sounds like perhaps you baked it in too small of a pan and that you didn’t’ bake it for long enough if it was ‘mush’. Next time I suggest following the recipe for best results!
Loved this cake. Family made it for my bday. Amazingly flavorful and moist!!! How many carbs? Do we know?
So happy you loved it, Kim! And sorry, we haven’t calculated the nutrition info for this recipe!
@Kim: I calculated approximately 51 grams of carbs in this recipe. That’s for 1 serving. There’s 16 servings in one cake. Hope this helps! 🙂
OMG this is delicious! This is like a good combination between a cake for dessert and banana bread for breakfast! It’s a must try for everyone!
Yay! I’m so glad you’re a fan, Leslie!
Amazing cake! The PB frosting was everything I had hoped for and more. Super easy and delicious, highly recommend. Wish I could upload a photo because it came out beautiful.
Oh yay!! So happy you loved it, Lacy. Feel free to tag @ambitiouskitchen on Instagram anytime!! 🙂
Have made this a multiple times and my whole family is a fan of it! WE LOVE IT!!!
Something to add as a recommendation, because it definitely did not occur to me, is to LEAVE THE CAKE AT ROOM TEMPERATURE for about 30-45 minutes before eating it, if storing in the fridge. It is soooo much better than eating it right out of the fridge.
Yay!! I’m so happy you guys love it 🙂 And good call on leaving it out at room temp!
The best cake ever! Honestly every one of Moniques’ recipes are amazing but I think this is my favourite dessert ever!!!!! Thank you for your hard work and bringing these amazing recipes to us !!!
Hi! Any substitutes for the coconut flour?
I haven’t tested this with anything else so I’m not sure, sorry!
I’m allergic to coconut. Is there a sub for the coconut flour? Thanks!
Sorry to say I haven’t tried anything so I can’t be sure! You may be able to replace it with an additional 1 cup of almond flour (since almond flour is less absorbent than coconut flour) but again, I haven’t tested it. Let me know if you try it!
I made this cake for my bosses birthday and he loved it! Very moist and delicious. The frosting is divine, will be using that on other desserts as well. Bravo, Monique!
Hi! I remember you had posted about using this as sid’s smash cake! How did you modify the frosting if at all? Thank you!! Love your recipes and can’t wait to make this for my little one!
Hi! Good memory 🙂 I halved the cake, baked it in 3 4-inch pans, and replaced the maple syrup with 2 tbsp. almond milk. And I halved the frosting and used just a tiny bit of powdered sugar!
Love this cake even without the frosting which I didn’t make. I cut the recipe in half and baked in 8 inch square pan for about 40 minutes.
So glad to hear that!!
Loved this recipe! I thought the ingredient list was concise for a gluten free cake. The texture and consistency was awesome as well.
I baked half in an 8in square pan and the remaining half in 4, 8oz ramekins to make a mini tiered cake for a bday.
Will def be making this again!
Can I use reg flour in this recipe?
I haven’t tested it and probably wouldn’t recommend subbing the flour, sorry!
Thank you for the recipe. Can I replace the coconut flour with only almond flour please?
Sorry, I don’t think that’ll work well! The coconut flour gives this cake the best texture.
Made this cake exactly as listed with one change. Did monkfruit powdered sugar instead of regular and only did half since it’s twice as sweet. Still made enough frosting and was delicious. Have made this cake 3-4x now and it always turns of perfectly. Both paleo and non paleo eaters all love it. Make it!!
So glad it turned out great, Brenna! Thanks so much for taking the time to leave a review 🥰
It looks delicious. Thank you for sharing this recipe.
Perhaps I should not leave a comment – I did not make the cake (it looks great!) i made the Peanut Butter Frosting to use as a filling in a chocolate cake, so this review if for the frosting only. It is FREAKING DELICIOUS! I have been looking for a PB Frosting recipe that specifically uses a natural PB and was delighted to come across this recipe. (Why would you make a frosting with PB that is already loaded with sugar??) Thank you for a delicious and sensible recipe!!
Thanks so much for commenting, Linda! So thrilled to hear you loved the frosting ☺️
I did not care for this cake it was edible and that is about it. I followed directions exactly and it was grainy and heavy and the chocolate chips overpowering. If it had more frosting, it would be an improvement.
Sorry to hear you didn’t love it, and thanks for the feedback! Really appreciate it. Just a quick question — did you use fine blanched almond flour, not almond meal?
Could I substitute the chocolate chips for walnuts ?
Absolutely!
Just wondering what you would use instead of powdered sugar? Is there a healthier option?
Feel free to try my paleo powdered sugar if you’d like! Just note that it will be much darker in color because it uses coconut sugar.
This recipe is banana bread but in cake form. We love the flavors of banana, pb and chocolate. I think I just hoped it would feel like a cake but the texture was off due to only using almond flour which is very grainy. Frosting wasn’t enough-need to double. If you love banana bread this is a great cake option. I prefer actual gf flour or oat to almond though.
Hi! Thanks so much for your feedback. Did you use fine blanched almond flour (not almond meal)?
Could you make this cake in a 9×13?
I have made this recipe a couple times! Definitely delicious and always a big hit with my guests 🙂
i read how you said us to stick to coconut flour but if you were to try substituting it what would you recommend?
I don’t have any other recommendations. I recommend sticking to the recipe for this one, enjoy!
Wonderful pictures you have shared along with the post . How important is the almond milk in your recipe ?
For the frosting? You can use any milk you’d like. Enjoy!
Turned out delicious! Made it a couple days in advance and it stored fine in the fridge.
Perfect! I am so glad you’re loving this cake 🙂
MONIQUE. I halved the recipe and made 12 cupcakes, and they were DIVINE!!! So soft, fluffy, and delicious! That frosting is so, so good!!
AMAZING! I am so glad you’re loving this recipe and it turned out amazing of you, Jessica 🙂❤️
The cake was awesome and I’m thinking of making it again for an upcoming birthday, but as cupcakes; do you have any recommendations?
Amazing! Yes, I would keep the baking time the same, divide the batter into your muffin/cupcake tin, and start with about 15-18 minutes baking time.
I love your recipes BUT I would like to ask if you can try to add some frostings that aren’t made with refined sugars. I can’t have it. You use a lot of alternatives in your baking such as maple syrup or dates, but there always seems to be refined sugar or powdered sugar in the frostings. Please help!
Hi! Feel free to try my paleo powdered sugar in the frosting recipes.
This is actually the best cake ever. It is the only cake I bake. Luckily everyone in my life loves it too, because its all we eat for every special occasion. It’s foul proof- I am notoriously lazy with measuring and even used a frozen/defrosted banana and its still perfect! I made it in a 9 by 13 and baked for about 25 minutes. It gets even better the next day after refrigerating. Thank you Monique!!!
Amazing! So glad you love this one!
I very rarely review a recipe but this one is special to me. I made this cake for my oldest son’s first birthday as his smash cake in a time of social distancing. He’s now 4. I then made it for my youngest’s first birthday. He’s now 2. It was an absolute smash hit both times (pun intended), and I remembered being proud of myself for making the cake myself. Now that we’re out of the craziest 2 under 2 times and I’m baking again I have made this a couple times. I now realize this is a ridiculously easy recipe & the result is much, much more luxurious than than the effort you put in. Add in the fact that it’s full of good-for-you ingredients and this recipe becomes a must for any mom’s repertoire. I’m so grateful for this healthy, easy, beautiful cake!
Aw I love that so much! Such a great treat for celebrating 🙂 Thanks for your note!
I just made this for my daughter’s birthday cake and it was delicious!! 🙂
Only other comment is that the icing in the pictures is very white! I used half the amount of peanut butter and subbed cream cheese for the other half (solely because I wanted to get rid of some cream cheese I had). It tasted great, but was definitely light brown (not white), and I assume it would have been even darker brown if I had used the full amount of peanut butter.
So happy to hear that! The color of the frosting in the photos is pretty beige / light brown if you check out the first photo (some of them the lighting just makes it look whiter!)
I used 2.5 cups of gluten free flour instead and added 1 tsp of baking powder and 1.25 top of xanthan gum and it turned out fine. Tastes more like the texture of banana bread rather than cake. And I used crunchy natural peanut butter as well cuz that’s what I had.
I’m glad that worked out well!
This cake is delicious! I haven’t made the frosting, for me it’s breakfast on the go or snack cake. I have made it as written, using crunchy peanut always (before making adjustments). This time I used peanut flour instead of almond flour (shell monkey nuts (peanuts) in a spice grinder until flour forms), with homemade coconut flour (made a greasy cake but still delicious! *I found out later that coconut flour is actually coconut pulp, not simply dried coconut whoops!). I don’t do much GF baking (not being allergic) but I love nuts, and it’s amazing to make a bake with nut flours, so nut is the star flavour not spices. And variety is the spice of life (?). Anyway thank you so much for sharing!
Love that! Glad those swaps have been working out well!
I don’t have a cake pan. Can I make these into muffins, and how long should I bake them for?
Yes, cupcakes should work! I would check them around 15 minutes.
I made the cake using 2 8″ pans. The instructions say 20-30 minutes if using the 8″ pans. I figured this time was way off but I went ahead. After 25 minutes, the toothpick test was clean so I took them out to cool. About 10 minutes later I checked on them and they weren’t firm in the middle. I read the instructions closer and realized the times for the 6 and 8″ pans must be mixed up. They’re back in the oven. I hope they turn out ok; a lot of expensive ingredients here.
Hi! The 8-inch cake pans won’t take as long because the cakes are not as dense, so the listed bake times for each pan size are correct. Let me know how they turned out!
I prepared this recipe for my birthday cake. It was spectacular!! My family loved the mix of flavors, especially the taste of the frosting. A total success.
Love that!! Such a great recipe for celebrating 🙂
The cake was sooo AMAZING!! We made it for a birthday and everyone loved it!! The frosting was the perfect addition to the cake! It tasted like a peanut butter cup! We used half of the frosting recipe for the cake because we prefer cake lightly frosted. I recommend starting with less powdered sugar that what it calls for in the frosting and then tasting from there. Love your recipes Monique!!
So happy to hear that! It’s one of my all time favorite cakes to make 🙂
This is so good! The cake is delicious, and the frosting is INCREDIBLE. I’m kind of putting it on everything I bake now 😀
So glad you love it!!
Hi! I am just checking to see if this recipe will work as a cupcake?
Yes, it should! Check them around 15 minutes.
Probably one of the best cakes I have ever made!
So happy to hear that!
The name of this recipe says it all – the cake is DAMN GOOD! I baked it as a single layer in a 9×13″ pan for 40 minutes and it came out perfectly. I wanted snack cake squares to pack in lunch boxes and for on-the-go after school snacks, I know I will be making this on repeat. Thank you for the delicious recipe!!
Great idea! So happy you loved this one!
Can I replace peanut butter with oil to get a neutral-flavored banana cake?
I wouldn’t recommend it! The texture and flavor will be much different.
Hi,
How Can I replace the coconut flour with oat flour?
Hi! I haven’t tested it, so I can’t be sure how the texture will turn out.
I tried this recipe, which turned out delicious, but can i increase mashed banana by 20g to increase banana flavor and subtitute oat flour for coconut flour?
I wouldn’t recommend changing those ratios or ingredients – sorry! Increasing the banana will likely make the cake too moist, and I haven’t tested the cake with oat flour. If you try either, just be sure to add a bit of extra flour if you add extra banana.
I always use this as our birthday cake but my question is can I use this for cupcakes?
Love that! And yes, absolutely!
Hi,
I tried this recipe and I made a mistake with banans measurement, it didn’t have that banana flavor and texture
3 very overripe medium bananas, mashed (1 ¼ cup mashed overripe banana), I used around 400g mashed banana
Can you give the approx measurement in grams? Please, I really want to make this recipe
Hi! I didn’t weigh the mashed banana for this recipe, but 3 medium ones should be plenty. I’d love a bit more info about the texture – was the cake overly dry? Or did it have a consistency like banana bread?
ohhh! Cake looks incredible, so Banana & Hazelnut is a deadly combo!
I want to make a Paleo chocolate hazelnut Buttercream, Can I use hazelnut butter instead of peanut butter and add cocoa powder to the frosting? Will the frosting be stable? How much hazelnut butter and cocoa powder to add?
It’s delicious! Hazelnut butter should work in the frosting in place of the peanut butter, but I’m not 100% sure how much cocoa powder you’ll want to swap in for some of the powdered sugar. I’d have to test it out first!
The best cake recipe ever! We use this for my son’s birthday every year and now people come FOR this cake!
So happy to hear that!!
I was a bit skeptical of this cake, but it turned out to be AMAZING!!! The peanut butter frosting was incredible, and the cake was so moist! I made them in two 9in cake pans and it turned out great. Will be making this cake again!
So glad you gave it a try! One of our favs!